Understanding PDA: What’s Really Happening in the Nervous System (Part 3)

Part 3 — The Nervous System Behind PDA (What’s Really Happening Inside)

One of the most life-changing shifts in my PDA parenting journey was realizing this:

My child wasn’t reacting to the task.
He was reacting to the pressure around the task.

For years, I tried to decode the “behavior” — the refusals, the shutdowns, the sudden “I’m done.”
But the truth was never in the behavior itself.
It was in what his nervous system was doing before the behavior.

And once I learned that…
I couldn’t unsee it.

The PDA Brain Is Wired for Protection, Not Compliance

A PDA child’s nervous system is always scanning the environment for pressure:

  • expectations
  • demands
  • eyes watching
  • time limits
  • rules
  • uncertainty
  • transitions
  • even praise (yes—praise can feel like pressure)

A demand enters the room, and their body reacts before their brain has time to form words.

Not because they’re dramatic.
Not because they’re manipulative.
Not because they’re oppositional.

Because their nervous system thinks it’s unsafe.

For many kids:
A demand = a request.

For a PDA brain:
A demand = a trap door.

And the body responds instantly.

Fight, Flight, Freeze… and the PDA Fawn/Mask Response

When people talk about fight, flight, and freeze, they forget the nuanced responses PDA kids often show:

🧠 Fight:
Not anger — panic wrapped in words.

🧠 Flight:
Leaving the room, shutting the laptop, turning away.

🧠 Freeze:
The silent stare. The stillness. The “I don’t know.”

🧠 Fawn/Mask:
“Okay…” (but their eyes say “no”)

The polite compliance that leads to a nuclear meltdown later.

Masking is the most misunderstood of all.
People see control, effort, politeness —
but underneath, the nervous system is burning through capacity.

And when capacity is gone, it’s gone.

Capacity: The Real Currency of PDA

If I could describe PDA in one visual, it would be this:

Capacity isn’t a bucket.
It’s bubbles.
And they pop quickly.

A bubble for:

  • transitions
  • communication
  • physical effort
  • unpredictability
  • social expectations
  • sensory input

Most kids can stretch a bubble. PDA kids… can’t.
Once the bubble pops, the only goal is safety.

This is why something tiny — a pencil breaking, a wrong turn, a therapist saying “one more” —
can cause a response that looks huge.

It’s not the event.
It’s the keystone that collapses the whole structure.

Why Pressure Feels Like Pain

This is the part I wish professionals would learn first:
Demands register in the PDA brain as threat — not challenge.

Even if the task is fun.
Even if the adult is kind.
Even if the child wants to do it.

The nervous system doesn’t distinguish between:

  • “Put your shoes on”
  • “Can you try one more time?”
  • “Do you want to play this game?”
  • “Let’s practice that again!”

Pressure is pressure.
And the moment the brain perceives it, survival mode begins.

Understanding this doesn’t excuse hard moments…
but it absolutely reframes them.

So What Helps? (The Short Version Before Part 4)

What helps a PDA nervous system isn’t compliance strategies.
It’s connection strategies.

Safety.
Autonomy.
Co-regulation.
Space without abandonment.
Options without pressure.
Predictability without rigidity.
Support without demand.

These aren’t “gentle alternatives.”
They are neurological necessities.

And once you work with the nervous system instead of against it, everything softens.

Next in the Series: Part 4 — Practical Ways to Reduce Pressure and Increase Connection

We’ll talk about:

  • scripts
  • gentle starts
  • autonomy-based choices
  • demand-free routines
  • sensory pacing
  • and how to build days that don’t implode before breakfast

Published January 22.

Back to blog